Even if you’re not a celebrity, being a senior executive, company owner, director and traveling via private aviation can make your a target for criminals. Whether you travel with valuables or not, thieves may believe you do. So even if you don’t have three million followers on Instagram, we think the following from our security contributors as AS Solution will be worth a read.
By Christian West & Brian Jantzen
The world was shocked by the news that Kim Kardashian was robbed at gunpoint in a Parisian apartment. The American celebrity and the French capital had again made headlines – this time, regrettably, for all the wrong reasons.
Although shaken by the incident, Kardashian was fortunately not harmed. In this column, we attempt to draw a few lessons from this tragic event from the perspective of executive protection professionals.
We’ll to try to understand the nature of what happened in a brief “after action review” so we can learn from it – and hopefully make it more difficult for something like this to happen again.
First off, let’s make one thing clear: This column is inspired by news stories we’ve read in the media like everyone else – not on facts that have been 100% verified.
Second, let’s make another thing even clearer: We’re not here to raise questions about any security agent or cast stones against colleagues in the industry. We know what it’s like to be in charge of protection, and we know that things can go south for any number of reasons.
Executive protection is not a one-person job, and it doesn’t take place in a vacuum. Like so many other things worth doing, protection is a team effort that can be enhanced by technology – and always faces financial constraints.
Like so many other things worth doing, protection is a team effort that can be enhanced by technology – and always faces financial constraints.
Protection specialists come in all shapes and sizes. We all have different types of training and backgrounds. One thing that we do have in common is that we all have to make do with what we’ve got, and do the best possible job with the available resources.
Jewels worth millions went missing. Various media have reported that Kardashian had been tailed by suspicious people, posing as paparazzi or police, prior to the robbery. Fingers are being pointed at everyone from Parisian police to lax security and Eastern European gangs. Talk of an “inside job” has captured imaginations.
We’re going to let all of these speculations rest, and focus instead on a few takeaways from the situation – and what we in the industry can do to minimize the probability of similar attacks.
What we – and many others – know about the victim and her situation.
Kim Kardashian is a high-profile celebrity that is in near-constant public scrutiny, has tens of millions of followers on social media, and is often in the news. As such, it’s no wonder that the perpetrators – along with millions of others – knew some important facts about Kardashian:
– She often carried valuable jewelry
– She was in Paris for Fashion Week
But the robbers knew more than that. Through either effective surveillance or a tip off, neither of which would be extremely difficult to come by, they could also figure out that:
– Kardashian was staying at a private residence
– She was protected by one unarmed security agent (who also keeps an eye on others in her entourage)
– She was likely to have even more jewelry than normal, since it was Fashion Week
Given this background, and the assumption that the perpetrators knew that Kardashian was in the apartment and that her security agent was with others in her group at a night club, five armed robbers overpowering one concierge and gaining access to Kardashian’s apartment is not an impossible task.
In fact, the heist would have to be considered a low-risk, high-reward job for the criminals.
So what could have been different…
There’s nothing like hindsight, and it’s easy to play armchair quarterback when it wasn’t your principal, your butt, and your budget constraints that were on the line of scrimmage. Still, a few tactical considerations are worth thinking about.
Given the principal’s apparent risks and vulnerabilities while in Paris, some measures could have been taken to make her a harder target.
…and what can other high-profile travelers do in order not to be the next victim?
– When possible, maintain a low profile.
– Check into hotels and other accommodations under a pseudonym.
– Utilize hotels and residences that have visible security personnel and systems.
– Do your social media posts and check-ins AFTER you leave a place where vulnerability might be higher than normal – instead of broadcasting your current location.
– Avoid time and place predictability.
– Based on risks inherent to high-profile activities and locations, and situations that preclude time and place predictability, be sure to staff properly for effective threat deterrence. This could include “residential” coverage (for private homes or hotels) as well as a halls & walls team. Consider this also when you have items of high value – not necessarily expensive jewelery – but things that many of our clients consider as “work tools” – laptops, cell phones, etc.
– Provide a way to communicate an emergency to your security staff, for example some kind of duress button/system.
– Utilize portable, temporary alarm and surveillance systems that are monitored by someone that can initiate local emergency response.
– Ensure your EP resources have training to identify hostile surveillance.
We hope that Kim Kardashian recovers from what was surely a traumatic experience and that she and her family remain safe, no matter where their travels take them.
We also hope that executive protection professionals everywhere will continue to learn from these unfortunate events, so that we can all work together to make things harder for the bad guys.